Thursday, May 16, 2013

INTRODUCTION



My Comm Major Experience
As a Communication Studies major at San Jose State University I have gained valuable knowledge and experience as not only a student, but as a human being trying to become a changing force in world that I will embark on in the coming months. I have never been more confident about my skills as a communicator and listener. Also, I have grown to understand that discourse or meanings that we have created about culture, society and the world can have several different viewpoints. For example, one culture may think that a raised fist above one's head is considered a condemned act that represents revolution, whereas another group of people may believe it is a sign of hope. It is up to the beholder to come to an understanding based on ones upbringing, education, or individual experiences. I have also been introduced to how new media has given way to new technologies that are making communication more accessible than ever before. I have been introduced to hybrid courses at SJSU where half the class is in person and the other is online. This has allowed me to be more efficient with my time and it has helped me become more organized by meeting strict deadlines. Overall, my experience has been a welcoming one that I will cherish until the end of time.

INQUIRY Course

Performance is the Key to Understanding
My Performance of Ethnodrama class has given me much insight on how performance can be used as a research method. This course was pivotal in my understanding of Inquiry courses at SJSU. In fact, it led me to demonstrate first hand how my research of ethical, critical, interpretive, performative and social scientific approaches are imperative to being a Communication Studies scholar. For instance, I learned that ethnography is the research method that studies how cultures and societies create knowledge and meanings amongst themselves. This course gave me an opportunity to be a storyteller for somebody else as well as a great listener. By doing so, I was able to see viewpoints other than my own. In the same way, when my classmates performed, I was an active participant as an audience member. Each story was engaging to where I could feel myself being pulled to be more open-minded about accepting people for who they are and where they come from. The performance that I will be writing about is when my classmate performed a story as a blind student. This paper advocates that through embodying performances and being skilled listeners, we can better understand how performance is used as a research method.

The final project for this class was to interview a person from a different cultural location than our own. That meant that we had to go out and find a person who had differences based on family upbringing, sexuality, disabilities, education, work, sports, music, movies and so forth. One of my classmates decided to interview her friend who is blind and she decided to embody him using simple props such as using a walking stick, a chair and a mirror. She did slight movements that made it seem like she wasn’t able to see by the way she moved her body and used her walking stick. As Soyini Madison wrote, “We know experience through the body. It is the embodied expression that organizes experience” (p. 167). My classmate was able to help us imagine what it might be like to be a blind person. I believe she was effective with the way she positioned her body and how she chose her movements because it wasn’t over the top. If I didn’t know any better, I would have thought that she was actually blind. Also, she made me realize how much I take for granted by being able to see. Equally important was how she used her voice to further tell her story.

It wasn’t a cultural shock as an audience member when viewing her movements because I have seen blind people before, but I was taken aback when she began talking about what it meant to be a normal person. She explained to her audience that being blind has not kept her from being able to do “normal” things, but that other people feel that she is not normal. Her commitment to dialogue helped resist “closure and totalizing domination of a single viewpoint, unitary system of thought” (Madison, p. 167). Basically, she was able to create a story for her audience that was open to different interpretations and that is what makes performance a much better method of bringing awareness about an important matter. Moreover, the climax of the story was the most integral part of the performance because she had made the audience part of her performance.

By the end of her performance, she used her mirror to reflect off her audience and she told us, “I may not see you, but I’m just like everybody else.” This dialogue, as well as her use of her prop, was pivotal in making her audience critically analyze what it means to be a blind person from several point of views. Every audience member was able to visualize themselves through her mirror and she made the point that “we are all the same” in our lives no matter if we are blind, deaf, or neither. Madison said, "The power dynamic of the research situation changes when the ethnographer moves from the gaze to the distance and detached observer to the intimate involvement and engagement of 'coactivity' or co-performance" (p. 168). I found myself able to really connect to who this person was. By involving her audience in her performance, we became involved in an amazing reflection of things we take for granted.

Naturally, it might be easy to say that performance is mere entertainment and does not belong in the education system. As a result, this type of thinking puts a negative image on performance as a research method because it is one distorted view of thinking. Conversely, there is a lot more to performance that people need to understand. My classmate did a great job of embodying her character by embracing the fact that she would have to be blind during her performance. When a person embodies a character, they are placing themselves into another person's shoes. They must make critical choices during the performance so that they can bring their character to life.

The whole process of creating and making performance is critical in engaging an audience to be analytical and to think outside the box. It is important to understand another person’s point of view in the world. We cannot be stuck to one viewpoint or bias towards a certain group of people or culture. As Dwight Conquergood stated, “[...] performance is now a power locus for research in the human sciences, a rallying point for scholars who want to privilege action, agency, and transformation” (Madison p. 149). If we can be more open to different cultures and points of view we will be able to see that performance as a research method can bring about change. And that alone, is quite powerful. 

Work Cited
Langelier K. & Peterson E. (2004). Storytelling in Daily Life. Temple University Press.
Philadelphia.
Madison, Soyini D. (2005). Ethnography: Method, Ethics, and Performance. Sage. Thousand
Oaks





FOUNDATIONS Course

Ethics of the Internet
For every building there needs to be a solid foundation. Without a solid foundation, a building will eventually crumble and fall apart with the aid of time and nature. In fact, the Department of Communication Studies has created a fantastic foundation for its undergraduates. This part of the curriculum is called Foundations which is about teaching students the fundamental theories and ethics associated with Communication Studies. Just as a building needs a solid foundation, college students need a foundation within their studies in order to succeed. I have gained valuable knowledge with my Foundations courses and one class in particular was able to set the solid foundation for my understanding of Communication Studies. During my New Media/ New World class, I wrote a paper where I discussed how new media technology and ethics relate to one another. The assignment met the Foundations learning objectives by demonstrating knowledge of theories and showing how ethics plays a pivotal role.
The ethical approaches of welfarism and preference utilarianism are quite contradictory towards each other. For instance, welfarism argues that the best actions is the one that most increases economic well-being or welfare; however, preference utilarianism holds that the best action is the one that leads to the most overall preference satisfaction (Ethics, 2012). Welfarism describes a situation that is open to greed and economic power and it can be compared to how internet service providers control Internet access for users. On the contrary, preference utilarianism strives to improve the experience of everyone (including internet users). These ethical approaches support two different sides of the Internet spectrum. Welfarism is backed by Internet service providers (ISPs) and preference utilarianism is supported by Internet users. The discussion for this paper is to find out what is ethical in terms of internet bandwidth speeds for Internet users. Should there be different levels of bandwidth (Internet speed) such as a gold, silver, and bronze levels where prices are fluctuated? Furthermore, should Internet users be entitled to high speed internet for a reasonable price?

The Internet explosion in the 1990s was a turning point in computer technology and it paved the way for ISPs to make a lot of money and deliver Internet service to millions of people. The National Science Foundation (NSF) had just privatized the Internet in 1992 and the Internet broke away from governmental control (Castells, 2003) [P. 30]. Today, ISPs are the Internet backbone for how users receive Internet access and there is no regulation to how the ISPs deliver their internet service. Companies such as Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, and Time Warner Cable have control over the bandwidth they sell to Internet users and it is difficult to say if these companies are making more money than they should. Although Internet service is much more convenient than it was 10 years ago, Internet users today are addicted to high speed Internet like never before. In order to “keep up with the Jones’”, Internet users are constantly in search of faster bandwidths because of the wealth of information users consume on a regular basis.

ISP’s are constantly trying to improve their financial standing or economic welfare. In order to do so, they must provide different levels of service. They also must compete with other ISPs who are looking to further their financial standing. This shows that welfarism is an important ethical approach for companies like Time Warner, Verizon, and so forth. Authors Meikle and Young write, “The Internet activities of corporations, large and small, are driven by profit, not by ideology, and it’s possible that particular implementations have apparently contradictory motivations” (2012)[p. 34]. For example, companies like Google use tactics to attract new users and expose them to advertisements that give Google revenue. Companies like Google and Verizon are always trying to make more money, but it is not a bad thing because it brings about competition for loyal customers. Google is the number one search engine in the world and it is where most people search for things on the World Wide Web. In fact, it is widely known that the term “googled” is quite popular amongst users. Every time a word is googled on the Internet, Google is making revenue.

The ethical approach of preference utilarianism is always on the mind of Internet users. There is always a need to get faster download and buffering speeds. What is slow today was super fast yesterday and what is fast today is slow tomorrow. It can be ethical for Internet users to receive the best of the best when it comes to Internet speed because Internet is no longer scarce. Chris Anderson from Wired Magazine writes, “The problem is that abundant resources, like computing power, are too often treated as scarce” (2009)[p. 1]. If ISP companies can quit being stingy with their abundant resources of Internet speed then they should be able to ethically give the people what they want. Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt writes, “[…] the phone and cable monopolies, who control almost all Internet access, want the power to choose who gets access to high-speed lanes and whose content gets seen first and fastest. They want to build a two-tiered system and block the on-ramps for those who can’t pay” (Meikle and Young, 2012)[p. 178]. The fact that ISPs are giving more opportunity for the users who can pay for the high speed Internet is something that seems very unethical. Internet users deserve the right to browse the World Wide Web at high speeds at reasonable prices, but there is a price to pay for good things.

Time is something that Internet users take for granted because they are so used to search engines working right away and watching Youtube videos at high resolutions with no glitches. Users are infatuated with speed and the ethical approach of preference utilarianism makes them feel entitled to the best Internet speeds possible. Recently, Google Instant has made Internet users’ search engine time much quicker by bringing up possible search inquiries by each stroke of the keyboard (Meikle and Young, 2012) [p. 163]. It is companies like Google and Apple that make people want to have the best things on the market whether dealing with smart phones, internet connections, or flat screen televisions.

Indeed, there are ethical problems that both ISP companies and Internet users face on a daily basis. One side needs to earn revenue to stay afloat and another wants to be treated equally when it comes to Internet access. Both welfarism and preference utilarianism can be opposites, but in reality, they can work together. For example, ISP companies are also big time media companies who are able to offer bundle packages for users who want phone, internet, and cable at a reasonable cost. Competition amongst other media companies allows prices for these bundles to be lowered. It is a win-win situation. Users get what they want for the best price possible and the provider gets revenue. Another example is how Google gets revenue from advertisers every time their search engine is used. The Internet user gets the information that they want and Google is able to advertise to more people. It is another win-win situation.

Ethically, there is no wrong or right answer to the question about Internet speeds. It will only get faster and technology will continue to grow. In effect, ISP companies will need to find a medium to meet the needs of Internet users every year such as having bundle packages readily available for them. There is always a desire to increase the speed and effect of messages through space for anybody using the Internet, but you cannot make everyone happy (Meikle and Young, 2012) [p. 167]. The ethical approaches of welfarism and preference utilarianism help in finding a solution to the problems ISP and Internet users face. Finding what is ethical and what is not is something that should be left for further discussion.

References
Anderson, Chris (2009). Tech Is Too Cheap to Meter: It's Time to Manage for Abundance, Not
Scarcity. Wired Magazine. Retrieved May 2, 2012, from http://www.wired.com/techbiz/it/magazine/17-07/mf_freer?currentPage=1

Castells, M. (2003). The Internet Galaxy: Reflections on the internet, business, and society.
USA: Oxford University Press.       

Coopman, T. M. (2012). Theory workshop: Ethics Comm 181F. Retrieved from
          https://comm181fonline.pbworks.com/w/page/49293601/Theory%20Workshop%20Ethics

Meikle, G., & Young, S. (2012). Media convergence: Networked digital media in everyday life.
New York, NY: St Martin’s Press LLC.

PRACTICE Course

Poetry Textual Analysis - COMM 121P

The assignment that I did in this course was a performance. My goal of the performance was to create an atmosphere for my audience to become a part of my story. We were given a prompt and a choice of oral interpretive stories that we could re-enact. I was able to fulfill the Practice learning objective in my Comm121 course called Performance as Practice by demonstrating the ability to communicate in various settings, such as interpersonal, small group, organizational, intercultural, mediated, and public communication. We perform in daily activities no matter if we are performers or bookworms. We choose to act a certain way in every context of our lives and it affects how we interact amongst one another. Also, by performing the story of another person, the audience can develop an understanding of how performance can create a change in the way we hear, think, and see.

The poem I chose to perform for my poetry performance is called Letter My Dad Never Gave Me by Corbet Dean. My instructor Marjorie Hazeltine gave me the poem and I was hooked after I skimmed over it. The poem is about a son who eventually became a police officer like his father. Apparently, the father never told his son about the bad things that police officers often experience. The speaker of the poem is the father, but it was written by the son most likely after the father passed away. So the father tells the son not to be a cop and that “every single cop becomes an asshole.” He goes on to say how excited he was to become a cop, but everything turned sour once he experienced the “life” of being a cop. The last line of the poem has the father realizing that it’s too late to save his son and he says “I’ve become the asshole I never wanted you to be.” This poem stood out to me because I’ve heard some frightening stories from former and current police officers. I have the upmost respect for police officers even though some may not be the best role models for kids. My performance of Corbet Dean’s “Letter My Dad Never Gave Me” explores the struggles of being a police officer and how it takes a huge emotional toll on a person. Throughout this paper I will articulate and defend specific performance choices using Burke’s pentad which include the agent, scene, action, agency, and purpose of Dean’s poem.

The agent of the poem is a police officer. He’s most likely a white, male that’s been in the police force for over 20 years so that makes him probably in his late 40s. He’s a wise and calm man who has changed a lot since he entered the force. For example, the speaker of the poem says, “Believe me, I didn’t start that way.” This makes me believe that he was different than he is today. Also, his tone is very stern and right to the point in his message. He’s a caring man, but his job has changed his perception of the world. He speaks as if he is right in front of his son and is personally involved in the discussion. He is omniscient of what goes on as a police officer and is very truthful. He describes a few scenarios where he takes the audience to his reality. 

The scene of the poem is in the speaker’s home. It’s one o’clock in the morning and he just came home from an undercover job in mid-February. The whole performance takes place in the living room. He’s shaken up and almost in tears as he walks in with blue jeans, a gray sweater, and a black beanie on. He’s jittery and he’s uncomfortable with his beanie and sweater so he throws them to the ground. His son was waiting all night long for his father to get home and he meets him in the living room. The man turns to his son and begins to speak to him. I determined that the speaker of the poem was talking to his son because he says in the first stanza, “If you think my job is fun, son […]” and also he uses the words “son” on four different occasions throughout the poem.

The speaker of the poem is trying to give advice to his young son. I believe his son is about seven or eight years old. He doesn’t want his son to see the things he has seen. He says in the last stanza, “And son, I need you to leave this world to me.” Also, the speaker talks about how he was before he became a police officer and then he tells some of the horrific crime scenes he’s been a part of. The speaker’s shows that he’s been hurt emotionally when he tells his son, “You’re gonna feel like you just renounced your soul.” He asks his son how well he “can lie” because that’s basically what a police officer has to do in some situations. The speaker is very dramatic when telling his stories and the poem is written in thirteen stanzas but there is no apparent rhyme scheme. The poem flows in chronological order as a free verse and the audience can feel like they are part of a conversation with the speaker. He uses simile when he uses the words “like” in the second stanza and third stanza. Also, imagery plays a big role in the poem. An example is when he describes the night he found a dead baby boy in a sewage drain in the rain.

The purpose of the poem is for the speaker to get his son not to become a police officer. He wants to convince his son that “there’s an awful lot of death in life no one should see.” The speaker’s audience is his son. As an audience, they will feel like the speaker is speaking to someone in the darkness. The audience should not affect what the speaker’s purpose is. I believe that the author of the poem will agree with his character’s view of the human condition because the author is a former police officer. The purpose is simple and in the second line of the poem the speaker states, “I’m not going to help you become one, too.” Thus, telling his son that he does not want him to become a police officer.

During my performance I will be able to show my audience the emotional toll and the internal struggles police officers can go through. Experiences shape a person and according to Corbet Dean, the experiences of his character has led him to believe that being a cop is not a job he wants his son to have. By using Burke’s Pentad my audience will be able to tell what character I am playing and they will know that I had just got home from a tough day at work. I will have dropped my gun on the counter and will frantically take off my sweater and beanie. They will also know my purpose once I begin to talk and I will start to slowly get my words across to the audience. I will not see the audience. What I will see is my son. I will make specific performance choices that will lead the audience to critically analyze my every move. Emotion will play a key role in getting my audience’s attention. I will change my tones and the speed of the way I say the words of the poem. In doing so, the audience will feel the emotion my character is conveying.