For every
building there needs to be a
solid foundation. Without a solid foundation, a building will
eventually crumble and fall apart with the aid of time and nature. In
fact, the Department of Communication Studies has created a
fantastic foundation for its undergraduates. This part of the curriculum
is called
Foundations which is about teaching students the fundamental theories
and ethics
associated with Communication Studies. Just as a building needs a solid
foundation, college students need a foundation within their studies in
order to succeed. I have gained valuable knowledge with my Foundations
courses and one class in particular was able to set the solid
foundation for my understanding of Communication Studies. During my New
Media/ New
World class, I wrote a paper where I discussed how new media technology
and
ethics relate to one another. The assignment met the Foundations
learning objectives by demonstrating knowledge of theories and
showing how ethics plays a pivotal role.
The ethical
approaches of welfarism and preference utilarianism are quite
contradictory towards each other. For instance, welfarism argues that
the best actions is the one that most increases economic well-being
or welfare; however, preference utilarianism holds that the best
action is the one that leads to the most overall preference
satisfaction (Ethics, 2012). Welfarism describes a situation that is
open to greed and economic power and it can be compared to how
internet service providers control Internet access for users. On the
contrary, preference utilarianism strives to improve the experience
of everyone (including internet users). These ethical approaches
support two different sides of the Internet spectrum. Welfarism is
backed by Internet service providers (ISPs) and preference
utilarianism is supported by Internet users. The discussion for this
paper is to find out what is ethical in terms of internet bandwidth
speeds for Internet users. Should there be different levels of
bandwidth (Internet speed) such as a gold, silver, and bronze levels
where prices are fluctuated? Furthermore, should Internet users be
entitled to high speed internet for a reasonable price?
The Internet
explosion in the 1990s was a turning point in computer technology and
it paved the way for ISPs to make a lot of money and deliver Internet
service to millions of people. The National Science Foundation (NSF)
had just privatized the Internet in 1992 and the Internet broke away
from governmental control (Castells, 2003) [P. 30]. Today, ISPs are
the Internet backbone for how users receive Internet access and there
is no regulation to how the ISPs deliver their internet service.
Companies such as Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, and Time Warner Cable
have control over the bandwidth they sell to Internet users and it is
difficult to say if these companies are making more money than they
should. Although Internet service is much more convenient than it was
10 years ago, Internet users today are addicted to high speed
Internet like never before. In order to “keep up with the Jones’”,
Internet users are constantly in search of faster bandwidths because
of the wealth of information users consume on a regular basis.
ISP’s are
constantly trying to improve their financial standing or economic
welfare. In order to do so, they must provide different levels of
service. They also must compete with other ISPs who are looking to
further their financial standing. This shows that welfarism is an
important ethical approach for companies like Time Warner, Verizon,
and so forth. Authors Meikle and Young write, “The Internet
activities of corporations, large and small, are driven by profit,
not by ideology, and it’s possible that particular implementations
have apparently contradictory motivations” (2012)[p. 34]. For
example, companies like Google use tactics to attract new users and
expose them to advertisements that give Google revenue. Companies
like Google and Verizon are always trying to make more money, but it
is not a bad thing because it brings about competition for loyal
customers. Google is the number one search engine in the world and it
is where most people search for things on the World Wide Web. In
fact, it is widely known that the term “googled” is quite popular
amongst users. Every time a word is googled on the Internet, Google
is making revenue.
The ethical approach
of preference utilarianism is always on the mind of Internet users.
There is always a need to get faster download and buffering speeds.
What is slow today was super fast yesterday and what is fast today is
slow tomorrow. It can be ethical for Internet users to receive the
best of the best when it comes to Internet speed because Internet is
no longer scarce. Chris Anderson from Wired Magazine writes, “The
problem is that abundant resources, like computing power, are too
often treated as scarce” (2009)[p. 1]. If ISP companies can quit
being stingy with their abundant resources of Internet speed then
they should be able to ethically give the people what they want.
Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt writes, “[…] the phone and cable
monopolies, who control almost all Internet access, want the power to
choose who gets access to high-speed lanes and whose content gets
seen first and fastest. They want to build a two-tiered system and
block the on-ramps for those who can’t pay” (Meikle and Young,
2012)[p. 178]. The fact that ISPs are giving more opportunity for the
users who can pay for the high speed Internet is something that seems
very unethical. Internet users deserve the right to browse the World
Wide Web at high speeds at reasonable prices, but there is a price to
pay for good things.
Time is something
that Internet users take for granted because they are so used to
search engines working right away and watching Youtube videos at high
resolutions with no glitches. Users are infatuated with speed and the
ethical approach of preference utilarianism makes them feel entitled
to the best Internet speeds possible. Recently, Google Instant has
made Internet users’ search engine time much quicker by bringing up
possible search inquiries by each stroke of the keyboard (Meikle and
Young, 2012) [p. 163]. It is companies like Google and Apple that
make people want to have the best things on the market whether
dealing with smart phones, internet connections, or flat screen
televisions.
Indeed, there are
ethical problems that both ISP companies and Internet users face on a
daily basis. One side needs to earn revenue to stay afloat and
another wants to be treated equally when it comes to Internet access.
Both welfarism and preference utilarianism can be opposites, but in
reality, they can work together. For example, ISP companies are also
big time media companies who are able to offer bundle packages for
users who want phone, internet, and cable at a reasonable cost.
Competition amongst other media companies allows prices for these
bundles to be lowered. It is a win-win situation. Users get what they
want for the best price possible and the provider gets revenue.
Another example is how Google gets revenue from advertisers every
time their search engine is used. The Internet user gets the
information that they want and Google is able to advertise to more
people. It is another win-win situation.
Ethically, there is
no wrong or right answer to the question about Internet speeds. It
will only get faster and technology will continue to grow. In effect,
ISP companies will need to find a medium to meet the needs of
Internet users every year such as having bundle packages readily
available for them. There is always a desire to increase the speed
and effect of messages through space for anybody using the Internet,
but you cannot make everyone happy (Meikle and Young, 2012) [p. 167].
The ethical approaches of welfarism and preference utilarianism help
in finding a solution to the problems ISP and Internet users face.
Finding what is ethical and what is not is something that should be
left for further discussion.
References
Anderson, Chris
(2009). Tech Is Too Cheap to Meter: It's Time to Manage for
Abundance, Not
Scarcity. Wired
Magazine. Retrieved May 2, 2012, from
http://www.wired.com/techbiz/it/magazine/17-07/mf_freer?currentPage=1
Castells, M. (2003).
The Internet Galaxy: Reflections on the internet, business, and
society.
USA: Oxford
University Press.
Coopman, T. M.
(2012). Theory workshop: Ethics Comm 181F. Retrieved from
https://comm181fonline.pbworks.com/w/page/49293601/Theory%20Workshop%20Ethics
Meikle, G., &
Young, S. (2012). Media convergence: Networked digital media in
everyday life.
New York, NY: St
Martin’s Press LLC.
No comments:
Post a Comment